| Welcome to Answering The Extremists. We hope you enjoy your visit. You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you will only be able to view topics. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free. Once you've registered, login and post in the INTRODUCE YOURSELF section and a Moderator will upgrade your account to allow you to post in other sections also. CLICK HERE To Join our community! If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features: |
| Islam and War | |
|---|---|
| Tweet Topic Started: Mar 15 2011, 02:01 PM (255 Views) | |
| Compatriot | Mar 15 2011, 02:01 PM Post #1 |
|
Moderator
|
The teachings of Islam on war have been misconstrued by both opponents of Islam and extremist Muslims. To clarify common misconceptions, we will look at the primitive sources of Islam for an authoritative explanation of Islamic teachings about war. The Nature of the Islamic Mission Islam has forbidden religious conversion by force and instead encourages human beings to accept Islam on the basis of reasoned arguments. Islam, the religion of nature and nature’s God, is clear, self-evident, and easy to understand. Therefore, to force others into Islam “would be an insult to it, would make it revolting, and would put obstacles in its way.” The Quran instructs us clearly that God did not wish people to become believers by way of force and compulsion, but only by way of study, reflection, and contemplation.” The following verses prove this point:
This point is further clarified by the stories of the Prophets in the Quran. Each Prophet is shown to have called his people to Islam not by compulsion but rather with beautiful preaching and reasoned arguments. The example of Noah:
The example of Abraham when he called his father to Islam using reason. Abraham said:
This method of beautiful preaching and reasoned argument is the basic rule Prophet Muhammad and his companions used to spread Islam. The following verses show this:
The following verses serve as additional proof:
This message is consistent throughout the Medinan (period in Islam denoted by the Prophet’s migration to Medina fleeing persecution and the Muslims had the freedoms to practice their faith) chapters as well:
One can summarize this section with the following points: 1.In the nature of the Islamic mission there is no complexity, obscurity, or unintelligibility that would require the use of manifest or secret compulsion. 2.The Islamic legislation, on the strength of the Book of God, is not in conflict with God’s principle of creation, which accounts for the fact that some people believe whereas others do not. This principle consists in leaving people free to choose for themselves the basis of examination and conviction. 3.The Islamic legislation, on the strength of the Book of God, rejects in plain and unambiguous words the use of compulsion as a means to propagate religion. 4.The Prophet of Islam was responsible towards his Lord only in so far as his missionary task was concerned. This task has been expounded in both the Meccan and Medinan parts of the Quran. It consisted in communicating the mission and admonition. He was not responsible for the conversion of people which might have induced compulsion and the use of force. 5.The Book of God, the source of the Islamic mission, does not respect faith brought about by compulsion, and it denies its having any consequence on the Day of Resurrection. How then can it enjoin compulsion or allow the use of it as a means to conversion? Therefore, religious freedom is paramount in Islam because God can only be truly worshipped by people who freely choose Him. Understanding the Verses of Fighting We must understand the context of the verses that discuss fighting non-Muslims, In Mecca, the Muslims suffered for several years under the worst kinds of punishment, oppressed in their religious freedom, persecuted for the sake of the creed in which they found reassurance and terrorized with regard to their property and personal safety. For all these reasons they were compelled to emigrate. They left their dwellings and settled in Medina, patiently submitting to God’s orders and gladly accepting His authority. The Muslims at first were forbidden to fight against their oppressors and the Prophet used to hold them back, saying, “I have not been ordered to fight.” Finally, in Medina, the following verses were revealed giving the Muslims permission to defend themselves:
This permission (to fight) was motivated by the fact that the Muslims suffered injustice and were forced to emigrate and to leave their dwellings without justification. These verses begin with God’s promise to “defend” the believers, indicating that what is discussed here is the law of self-defense. The right of self-defense is recognized in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 12:
The right of self-defense belong not only to Muslims but to all people, as mentioned in the verse, “If God did not repel some people by means of others, many monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques, where God’s name is much invoked, would have been destroyed.” As such, Jews, Christians, and other people have the right to defend themselves if Muslims transgress by unlawfully attacking them. The next verses reiterate this point but ask the believers to be exercise restraint and forgiveness should hostilities towards them stop:
The above verse clearly prohibits the provocation of hostility and this prohibition is reinforced by God’s repugnance of aggression and by his dislike of those who provoke hostility. It then points out that expelling people from their homes, frightening them while they are safe, and preventing them from living peacefully without fear for their lives or possessions is persecution worse than persecution by means of murder and bloodshed. This is how the verse was understood by the companions of the Prophet, the earliest Muslims, and popular classical authorities of Islam, as shown by the following reports:
Some opponents of Islam cite the phrase, “Fight them until there is no more persecution, and worship is devoted to God,” also repeated in verse 8:39, as a prescription for conquest, but this verse was revealed so that people obtain religious freedom and are not oppressed or tortured because of their religion. This is proven by the phrase immediately following it, “If they cease hostilities, there can be no [further] hostility except towards aggressors.” In these verses and the principle they contain with regard to the reason and aim of fighting, there is not a single trace to be found of any idea of conversion by force. On the contrary, these verses, like the previous ones, say in plain and distinct words that the reason for which Muslims have been ordered to fight is the aggression directed against them, expulsion from their dwellings, violation of God’s sacred institutions, and attempts to persecute people for what they believe. At the same time they say that the aim upon the attainment of which Muslims must cease fighting is the termination of aggression and establishment of religious freedom devoted to God and free from any pressure or force.” There are many more verses that confirm this basic principle:
If one reads these verses carefully, then you will realize that these verses were revealed with regard to people lawlessly practicing persecution, amongst whom the elements of depravation were so deeply rooted that they did not respect pledges anymore and that virtue became meaningless to them. There is no doubt that to fight these people, to purify the earth from them, and to put an end to their persecution is to serve the commonwealth and benefaction of mankind as a whole. Finally, lets look at two verses which are commonly misunderstood. In these examples, we see the importance of interpreting the Quran as a complete book rather than interpreting verses in isolation. The first verse reads:
To understand this verse we must look at verses prior to it in the same chapter. They tell us that those groups mentioned here are the aggressors, namely the Byzantine Romans, who did not honor peace treaties with the Muslims:
Therefore, this verse does not say that the quality of being a disbeliever constitutes a sufficient reason for fighting them. This has always been the majority position of the four orthodox Sunni schools of law: Among the four Sunni schools of jurisprudence only one, the Shafi‘ee school, contains the view that a person’s belief can be a reason for fighting against them. This view, however, is mitigated by the fact that an opposite view, in agreement with the majority, is also attributed to Shafi‘ee. [Jihad and the Islamic Law of War, Royal Aal al-Bayt Institute for Islamic Thought, p. 36] The prescribed tax was the method used to pacify opponents subdued in war or to ally with those who wished to be protected by the Muslim armies. The poll-tax is not as some people think, a sum paid in return for the right to refuse conversion to Islam or in return for their lives. It is, as we have said, a symbol of their submission (to the law) and for their desistance from fighting and impeding the Islamic mission, and a token of their participation in the affairs of the state, which grants them protection of their lives and properties. This is further proven by the Hanafi scholar Abu Yusuf in his Book of Taxes (Kitab al-Kharaj):
In this example, the Muslim leader returned the taxes he collected when he discovered he was no longer able to protect the people of Syria from the Byzantine Romans. So rather than an instrument of theft or oppression, this tax was intended to be a fair contractual relationship that Muslims were obligated to honor. In this respect, Umar ibn Abdul Aziz said, “God did not send Muhammad as a tax collector, but rather as a guide for humanity.” The second misunderstood verse reads:
The previous verses clearly determined the reason and aim of fighting. Having been established then, this verse discusses a practical battle plan for defending against aggression already underway. The command is to fight the hostile enemies nearest to the Muslims so that the road can be cleared for use by common people. In this case, the disbelievers refer to “those hostile polytheists who fight the Muslims, commit aggression against them, expel them from their homes and property and persecute them because of their religion.” We can conclude this section with the following points: 1.That there is not a single verse in the Quran which could support the opinion that the aim of fighting in Islam is conversion. 2.That there are only three reasons for fighting: to stop aggression, to protect the mission of Islam, and to defend religious freedom. 3.That in giving its prescriptions for fighting, the Quran did not allow greed, selfishness, and humiliation of the poor as motives for it, but intended it as an instrument for peace and tranquility and for a life founded on justice and equality. 4.That the poll-tax is not a financial compensation for the granting of one’s life or preservation of one’s own religion, but a symbol of submission (to the law) and desistance from harmful acts and a contribution in carrying the burdens of the state. The Islamic Charter on Relations with Non-Muslims The Islamic charter concerning the relationship between Muslims and non-Muslims can be summarized in the finding from the following verse:
This verse clearly distinguishes between aggressive and peaceful non-Muslims. The reason these verses were revealed was to make this distinction, as recorded in the authentic tradition:
Although Mecca and Medina were not on friendly terms at the time, the Prophet gave Asma bint Abu Bakr permission to treat her polytheist mother well, knowing that she was a peaceful woman. She was not in the same category as Abu Jahl or Abu Lahab, who were the leaders of violent oppression against the new Muslim community. The verses of forgiveness and the verses of fighting do not contradict each other nor abrogate each other. Rather, they apply to different categories of people; namely, the verses of forgiveness apply in general to all people, whereas the verses of fighting apply only to those who initiate aggression or commit crimes. Legislation based upon consideration for different situations, and for different conditions of individuals and groups, a legislation that requires of people that they follow in every situation that which is most suitable, cannot be accused of being inconsistent or of being a legislation of which one part abrogates the other. People with common sense will consider it as a wise and very precise legislation that promotes the interest of those who fall under its authority and will realize its ultimate aim: the happiness of the individual and the community. The Aim of Peace and Good Will I will mention here some additional texts which prove that the aim of fighting in Islam is the establishment of peace and religious freedom. The Holy Quran states:
Ibn Kathir explains this verse by citing the following report:
As we can see, the Prophet commanded his close companion Ali, the fourth rightly guided Caliph, to seek a peaceful solution to conflicts whenever possible. This has always been the basic understanding of war in Islam. That war is to be fought only as a last resort is further established by the following report:
In general, the Prophet taught his companions to spread a climate love and harmony amongst themselves and others, and that this is done by establishing peaceful relations:
As such, peace treaties are sacred in Islam. The Prophet warned his companions in the strongest terms that whoever breaks his peace treaty will go to Hell:
Furthermore, the Prophet characterized lawless killing and bloodshed as a rejection of God and His laws:
For all of these reasons, Islamic legal theorists have universally accepted that the objectives of Islamic law (Maqasid al-Sharia) are the protection of life, religion, property, family, mind, and honor. Imam Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, one of the most brilliant Muslim thinkers in history, writes:
Conclusion Islam teaches just war theory as an instrument for the maintenance of peace and human rights, specifically the rights of life, safety, and religious freedom. Islam has forbidden conversion by force and allows war only to repel aggression and injustice. The normative relationship between Muslims and non-Muslims is peace and good will, as clearly stated in the Holy Quran. This has been the view of Muslims since the time of Prophet Muhammad until our time today. If Muslims ever fail to live up to these ideals, it is because of their inability or unwillingness to support the Islamic mission according to the method of Prophet Muhammad. The Prophet is free from all of those who commit injustice in the name of Islam. May God send His peace and blessings be upon Prophet Muhammad, his family, and his followers altogether. Ameen. |
| Light travels faster than sound. That's why most people seem bright until you hear them speak. ~Author Unknown | |
|
|
| The Peace Professor | Mar 16 2011, 05:29 PM Post #2 |
|
This article is an excellent explanation into why Islam allows war & under what conditions!!! Its a bit long but I guess that is necessary to do justice to the subject which is hugely misunderstood by non-Muslims. If you read through the full article you will realise that Islam is a religion of peace & actively establishes it!!! As for those who say Muslims are hiding their real agenda by a means of lying (Taqiya) then what can you say to this article which is quoting from Islam's primary sources The Holy Qur'an & the Sunnah (Traditions of the prophet) without which there is no religion left?
|
|
Join up to this Forum & help protect Islam:(Please click & join) For Any One who wants to post in this Forum you need to post a New Thread in: Introduce Yourself!!! (This is for us to get to know you, so we can upgrade your profile to jnr member) | |
|
|
| A MAN OF FEW WORDS | May 9 2012, 09:12 PM Post #3 |
|
salam nice work |
| "The world is darkness; knowledge is light; but knowledge without truth is a mere shadow." ALI (RA) | |
|
|
| James Scott | May 9 2012, 10:40 PM Post #4 |
![]()
Moderator
|
excellent..bring us more Compatriot |
|
Allah says "Let there be no compulsion in religion, indeed truth and guidance is made crystal clear from ambiguity and falsehood" TMQ - Chapter 2 verse 256. He most high and blessed also said: "Indeed, We hurl the Truth against falsehood, and it knocks out its brain, and behold falsehood does perish! TMQ- Chapter 21 verse 18. | |
|
|
| 1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous) | |
| « Previous Topic · Lessons In Islam · Next Topic » |
| Theme: Zeta Original | Track Topic · E-mail Topic |
9:42 AM Jul 11
|


This article is an excellent explanation into why Islam allows war & under what conditions!!!


9:42 AM Jul 11