Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]


Locked Topic
Day 2
Topic Started: Sep 1 2011, 08:58 PM (3,702 Views)
Salome
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Johnny
Sep 3 2011, 03:56 PM
While waiting for the next part.

Chalros post sounded like it was not his own idea. He needed almost an hour to explain his three suspects.
Yeah. It felt like he was rereading everything to search for something to support his flimsy cases, like that point about Hoe's flip-flopping feels like it's lifted straight from one of my posts.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Hoe: N/A
Johnny: N/A
Kalifa: N/A
Saint Charlos: No Lynch
Akainu: No Lynch, Koshiro
Boa Hancock: No Lynch, Saint Charlos
Koshiro: No Lynch, Chopperini
Gekko Moria: No Lynch, Akainu
Salome: No Lynch, Akainu
Spacey: Akainu
Chopperini: Akainu
Ryuuma: Koshiro, Akainu
Iceburg: Saint Charlos, Akainu
Miss Merry Christmas: Koshiro, Akainu
Straw Hat: Boa Hancock, Akainu

The first thing that draws my attention, is naturally at the top of the list. Three people who didn't provide town with anything to work with. It is a complete detriment. If you posted on Day One, you had time to put down a vote. All three of you posted.

Hoe got my vote, because of the amount of time he spent 'active' without contributing. Admittedly Kalifa and Johnny aren't that far off either. Both have been a lot more active today, but it's simple enough to speculate that, that is a reaction to their performance yesterday. Kalifa's kill certainly doesn't make her look any better.

Next come the No Lynchers. It isn't that incriminating to vote No Lynch in general, but I certainly make a note as to who does it. The only time that you can safely get on that wagon is on Day One, or Mylo. The word that comes to mind is safe. It's very easy to get the day over with, without making enemies the next day, or having to justify yourself if a wagon goes mislynch. Even Charlos threw a little animosity my way. I wonder why?

Lastly are the aggressors, of whom two have died. Big surprise there. Spacey and Chopperini are sort of in the middle in that respect. I'd really love to see more votes coming from both of them. There's only so much that you can chalk to Day One before you're looking for an excuse. They helped get the wagon moving, so I can't say they weren't helping, but the fact that they didn't have anything else before Akainu's wagon is bothersome.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Nmaa...that took longer than I expected.

...I shoulda' probably have spread this out, huh? Ah, well.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
It's not that much. No need to spread it out. While I agree to the gist of it, I was expecting a bit more after the long wait for it.

I looked at the votings, as well. Gekko, Hoe, Salome and Spacey stood out for me, especially if looking at what they posted throughout the day. Gekko has the innocent in his favor. I'm still looking at the other three. For Kalifa I don't mind the not voting. She wasn't really there. It's more the assassination of MMC that bothers me.

I will comment on my absence one last time. I didn't want to lurk, I just couldn't be here. I even said so during the day. If I was there I still wouldn't have voted no lynch. No lynches can happen when no target is found until the day ends. I still never vote to have one. Also, I would have rather followed the Chalros lynch than the one on Akainu.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chopperini
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Can't say I's too happy with what I see comin' back. Still too many people hidin' behind the "I don't got no ideas" bit. Worse, ain't many people who seem ta have a big problem with it. I gave yous all plenty of time now, at the expense of gettin' criticized.

Kalifa, questionin' me for bein' aggressive makes my eyebrow raise. Ya ain't said nor done nothin' useful this game, other than admit what ya did, so I wanted people like you ta TALK and THINK. "It was only 5 pages that I didn't read, now leave me alone" ain't gonna put me at ease none.

Hoe, y'ain't replied to my further prod, seein' as yer first response was unsatisfyin', not ta mention I believe Hancock asked a question too. The most I got outta ya was very light suspicions with no explanations. Lots of posts, lots of general opinions, no explainin'. An' I can't get past that mistake, it's been botherin' me all along.

Vote Lynch: Hoe
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Johnny
Sep 3 2011, 05:26 PM
It's not that much. No need to spread it out. While I agree to the gist of it, I was expecting a bit more after the long wait for it.

I looked at the votings, as well. Gekko, Hoe, Salome and Spacey stood out for me, especially if looking at what they posted throughout the day. Gekko has the innocent in his favor. I'm still looking at the other three. For Kalifa I don't mind the not voting. She wasn't really there. It's more the assassination of MMC that bothers me.

I will comment on my absence one last time. I didn't want to lurk, I just couldn't be here. I even said so during the day. If I was there I still wouldn't have voted no lynch. No lynches can happen when no target is found until the day ends. I still never vote to have one. Also, I would have rather followed the Chalros lynch than the one on Akainu.
Would you mind explaining what you mean by 'expecting more', Johnny?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Kalifa, what do you think of Koshiro? Is he someone that you would consider lynching?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
I still have a hard time to get a grasp of the ongoings. I was hoping for something that I might have overlooked. It might have sounded harsher than I intended it to do. I still had to go shopping and I was getting impatient.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Ryuma
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Vote Lynch: Hoe

After rereading and looking over my notes my top suspect is Kailfa, but I want to achieve a lynch so I'll vote Hoe (Who is also very high on my list).

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Ryuma
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
What's the voe count and how much longer until the day ends?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Day Threads · Next Topic »
Locked Topic