Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]


Locked Topic
Day 2
Topic Started: Sep 1 2011, 08:58 PM (3,718 Views)
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Apparently the mafia killed the Straw Hat. According to my notes, he was suspicious of Akainu and Boa yesterday. Boa didn't do much apart from No Lynching but we several people like that around.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Iceburg
Sep 2 2011, 03:14 AM
So you're saying that it would save someone at the cost of yourself? It's not a straightforward protection power?

Also: Really? Not one person you'd want to protect?
The target gets protected and either I or the attacker would have died. I was paranoid and afraid of covering a mafia player while killing a vigilante (or myself) so I refrained from using it.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kalifa
Member Avatar
inept treasure hunter
Iceburg
Sep 2 2011, 02:51 AM


Did you think that she wouldn't be lynched the next day, so you had to shoot her sooner than later?

I needed a target, that is all. And she seemed the most suspicious in my eyes.

Also, I kind of didn't get the suspicion on Koshiro, can someone explain that? (I have to explain that I didn't read the middle part [after I said that you guys should stop spamming] of yesterday's thread)
That I was absent wasn't on purpose. I just.. forgot about the game, lol. When I remembered, I was too tired, so I thought I will just look at it in the morning, which I did. It was night, I had the gun and read the last 20-30 pages to pick myself a target.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Nmaa...you don't need notes to see...nevermind.

Your fears aren't unfounded, but seem lackluster. Paranoid is a suitable term, I'd say. It goes without saying that you wouldn't protect someone you thought was mafia. But refusing to protect anyone is just not productive. The odds of two townies thinking the exact opposite of the same target? If that actually happened, then at least town has a better chance of being unified.

It's like saying you don't want to lynch someone because you're afraid that you're lynching a villager. Or worse, that you'll be lynched in response to a mislynch. Doing nothing helps the mafia, remember?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Quote:
 
Also, I kind of didn't get the suspicion on Koshiro, can someone explain that?
All I have is that his first post was a No Lynch and some misunderstanding (?) about his role PM and potential third parties.

Quote:
 
Your fears aren't unfounded, but seem lackluster. Paranoid is a suitable term, I'd say. It goes without saying that you wouldn't protect someone you thought was mafia. But refusing to protect anyone is just not productive. The odds of two townies thinking the exact opposite of the same target? If that actually happened, then at least town has a better chance of being unified.

It's like saying you don't want to lynch someone because you're afraid that you're lynching a villager. Or worse, that you'll be lynched in response to a mislynch. Doing nothing helps the mafia, remember?
It was the risk of losing a townie and saving a mafia player at the same time that scared me. However small the possibility. I just would have been really mad at me if that had happened. But it was probably a little selfish.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Kalifa
 
That I was absent wasn't on purpose. I just.. forgot about the game, lol. When I remembered, I was too tired, so I thought I will just look at it in the morning, which I did. It was night, I had the gun and read the last 20-30 pages to pick myself a target.
Nmaa...Maybe you don't do that next time. B|

As for Koshiro, the suspicion on him was more or less the same as say... Ms. Merry Christmas. He was doing his own thing, which some people felt meant that he wasn't going to go along with what town wanted. He made some minor speculation about third parties, was the first to claim receiving an item, and Ms. Merry Christmas threw a quick finger of suspicion his way. From what I see, it's the same deal as Ms. Merry Christmas. He's definitive with statements, and isn't looking to compromise. He rubs people the wrong way, I guess.

Regardless, I won't put a vote on him at this time. There are people who are more worthy of attention at this time.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Spacey
 
It was the risk of losing a townie and saving a mafia player at the same time that scared me. However small the possibility. I just would have been really mad at me if that had happened. But it was probably a little selfish.
Nmaa...Maybe you don't do that next time. B|

XD
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Iceburg
Sep 2 2011, 03:54 AM
Regardless, I won't put a vote on him at this time. There are people who are more worthy of attention at this time.
I said 'at this time' twice. I think I need to sleep some.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Hoe
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Hooooooooeeeeeeeeeeeeee is sad that Iceburg feeeels that way. I don't liiiiike lynching when there is so little to gooo by. That's just how I plaaaay~.

Iiiii have a question. Gekko Moria, how was your niiiiight?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Hoe
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Aaand I will sing a sad whaaaaaale song to mooooouuuuuuurn Straw Hat and to a leeeesser extent Miss Merry Christmaaaaas.

Sorry for the double poooost~.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Day Threads · Next Topic »
Locked Topic