Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]


Locked Topic
Day 2
Topic Started: Sep 1 2011, 08:58 PM (3,715 Views)
Koshiro
Member Avatar
inept treasure hunter
MODS: Can we get a list of names of all the current players at the beginning of each Day? Preferably, everyone's name when vote counting.

Quote:
 
So what's your theory, then? Killers bein' all un-professional-like and leavin' behind evidence? That don't make sense to me.

Akainu was lynched, not murdered, and it was 'fore none of us even had a chance to open our items. An' he died clasping and melting his item.

And since 2 of us woke up dead this morning, I'm assuming one of 'em was shot with a gun. Hence the logical conclusion, in my opinion 'course, that there's 2 guns and therefore could be 2 of anything.

Also if ya read the opening post carefully, the broken scanner was found next to the mole. So's I was assuming the hat was the one who was item-less. And with a grand total of 6 posts, it don't strike me as unlikely that he ain't found any item of his own. That, and hats probably ain't so good at digging.


Reading all the post up to now I realize it's "possible" players killed by a Townie don't get their item destroyed. I'm not going to assume Straw didn't have a item. I got mine during my first couple posts.

Ryuma answered my questions. I'm going to drop it for now and focus on others.

Unvote
Vote Lynch: Chopperini


I really didn't like how you jumped in to help Ryuma. What was your item and who did you use it on?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Koshiro
Member Avatar
inept treasure hunter
Double post, ignore.


Sure no prob Koshiro...
and done...
Edited by Gaimon, Sep 2 2011, 07:24 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chopperini
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Koshiro
Sep 2 2011, 07:17 AM
I really didn't like how you jumped in to help Ryuma. What was your item and who did you use it on?
My item was passive and absolutely useless to me, and I'd rather not say exactly what it is until more people come.

You can think about possibilities all you want. Just remember the common words of wisdom that you should try to make sense of what happened in accordance with the rules/roles, not make sense of the rules/rules in accordance with what happened.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Ryuma
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Koshiro
Sep 2 2011, 07:17 AM
Reading all the post up to now I realize it's "possible" players killed by a Townie don't get their item destroyed. I'm not going to assume Straw didn't have a item. I got mine during my first couple posts.
M. M. C. was killed by a townie (not a confirmed townie though). So it is likely the mafia killed Straw hat, but just because you got your items in six posts doesn't mean he did.

Another reason he wouldn't have an item could be a second exchange paper.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chopperini
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Well it's time for me to slide on out of this joint (no grease joke intended). Catch up with you all in some hours.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gecko Moria
Member Avatar
adept treasure hunter
Told you guys i would be coming a whole buncha hours later. Anyway Hoe why did you specifically ask about my action?

There are plenty of other players who haven't said anything if they did anything or not.

Also i propose we keep Charlos as a backup lynch of we haven't formed enough of an suspicion on anyone else. Even if he is a mafia i doubt he's much use....

I'm off to reread the day so far now.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Koshiro
Member Avatar
inept treasure hunter
Ryuma
Sep 2 2011, 07:25 AM
Koshiro
Sep 2 2011, 07:17 AM
Reading all the post up to now I realize it's "possible" players killed by a Townie don't get their item destroyed. I'm not going to assume Straw didn't have a item. I got mine during my first couple posts.
M. M. C. was killed by a townie (not a confirmed townie though). So it is likely the mafia killed Straw hat, but just because you got your items in six posts doesn't mean he did.

Another reason he wouldn't have an item could be a second exchange paper.
The Mafia destroyed Merry Xmas's ID Scanner, seeing her as a threat but not killing her because she started Akainu's lynch. They hoped we'd lynch her. If that's true then one Mafioso can kill and another can destroy items.

Quote:
 
My item was passive and absolutely useless to me, and I'd rather not say exactly what it is until more people come.

You can think about possibilities all you want. Just remember the common words of wisdom that you should try to make sense of what happened in accordance with the rules/roles, not make sense of the rules/rules in accordance with what happened.

No waiting! I want the name. NO ONE tell the name of their item until Chopper does!
I want to know if you're lying about having an item.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Koshiro
Sep 2 2011, 10:58 AM
The Mafia destroyed Merry Xmas's ID Scanner, seeing her as a threat but not killing her because she started Akainu's lynch. They hoped we'd lynch her. If that's true then one Mafioso can kill and another can destroy items.

Quote:
 
My item was passive and absolutely useless to me, and I'd rather not say exactly what it is until more people come.

You can think about possibilities all you want. Just remember the common words of wisdom that you should try to make sense of what happened in accordance with the rules/roles, not make sense of the rules/rules in accordance with what happened.

No waiting! I want the name. NO ONE tell the name of their item until Chopper does!
I want to know if you're lying about having an item.
Why are making this so complicated? I naturally assumed that "dead player" = "destroyed item that player held". And I see nothing to go against that theory yet.

I also want to know the name of the item although I can't see why he would lie about having one.


Im going to work now...be back in about 7 hours...
Edited by Gaimon, Sep 2 2011, 11:45 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
I'm back. I was a doctor last night, maybe the doctor since nobody else claimed this. With two deaths I'm pretty sure I failed my job.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Koshiro
Member Avatar
inept treasure hunter
Spacey
Sep 2 2011, 11:36 AM
Koshiro
Sep 2 2011, 10:58 AM
The Mafia destroyed Merry Xmas's ID Scanner, seeing her as a threat but not killing her because she started Akainu's lynch. They hoped we'd lynch her. If that's true then one Mafioso can kill and another can destroy items.

Quote:
 
My item was passive and absolutely useless to me, and I'd rather not say exactly what it is until more people come.

You can think about possibilities all you want. Just remember the common words of wisdom that you should try to make sense of what happened in accordance with the rules/roles, not make sense of the rules/rules in accordance with what happened.

No waiting! I want the name. NO ONE tell the name of their item until Chopper does!
I want to know if you're lying about having an item.
Why are making this so complicated? I naturally assumed that "dead player" = "destroyed item that player held". And I see nothing to go against that theory yet.

I also want to know the name of the item although I can't see why he would lie about having one.


Im going to work now...be back in about 7 hours...
Doesn't matter if dead=destroyed. I want to know if Chopper is lying about having an item.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Day Threads · Next Topic »
Locked Topic