Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]


Locked Topic
Day 3
Topic Started: Sep 5 2011, 06:22 PM (1,933 Views)
Boa Hancock
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Well, to answer your question. No, i won't hammer, cause it was requested that I not do so to gather more information. So you have the option of hammering yourself, or not hammering so that we may continue to gather information. If you truly are town, you will let us do so.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chopperini
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Iceburg
Sep 6 2011, 06:15 PM
As for the gun, I'd say that it should be used. In a mylo situation, (Not that we know we're in one,) you shouldn't lynch because you can wait for better odds. At the same time, as long as you lynch right, there's no reason to wait. A gun is just another chance to lynch, without spending an entire day phase on discussion. If we weren't going to No-Lynch, then there's no reason to No-Kill.
Maybe you ain't thinkin' about it from the same angle as the rest of us? We're makin' the assumption that there's 3 scum, in which case a mislynch + misfire = game over. If there's 4 of 'em then a mislynch is game over either way (barrin' extreme luck at night). Usin' a gun seems way too reckless at that point.

Now I see Ryuma's kinda givin' up... maybe he don't wanna give us nothin' to analyze after his flip. So if we settle the gun issue, I don't see no point in prolongin' the day, unless people're missin' items. I won't hammer yet at any rate, but I don't see no point in waitin' forever.

In the meantime, since everybody's been givin' essays on suspects, I guess my silence would make my murder less risky for the mafia than if I speak up, so here's a few thoughts.

What I can say now after readin' some stuff over is Boa an' Salome are two players who seem to say just about what you'd expect from a townie without puttin' too much effort or initiative in. They explain their reasonin' but it usually ain't terribly insightful beyond what's already on the table. Then on the one hand Boa was very definitive about what she'd do with her item at least, while Salome wasn't consistent with what she said about it. Both seem like "subjects of interest."

Iceburg, you're a tough cookie to weigh in on. You got generally long posts that are carefully and logically constructed, an' ya seem to consider all angles but not be afraid ta be decisive. The only thing that be botherin' me right now's your no item claim, which was even worded kinda vaguely. 24 posts an' no item? I'm slightly skeptical, considerin' everyone else got one. And some of our items were confirmable to varying extents, but for those who weren't, lyin' at least woulda put 'em in danger of someone else claimin' the same item. "I got no item" seems like a kinda easy way out of that, and I'm surprised nobody doubted it at all.

That said, I could make a similar case against Spacey. He's the only one who ain't used his item on night 1, and his posts also seem carefully constructed an' logical. But I don't get no real vibes from neither of 'em.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Iceburg
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Nmaa...the point of me putting you at L-1 Ryuuma, among other things, is so that you show your 'true colors', as it were.

I want to know what you think of everyone. Hell, anyone. Your flip will tell us what we want to know. If you're just going to accept your fate, then I don't know what keeps you from hammering yourself. If you're trying to stretch the day into a No-Lynch, it won't happen. Even if I unvote you, it doesn't change your position.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Ryuma
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Vote Lynch: Ryuma

There isn't much left to discuss so I'm just going to hammer.

My top suspects are Boa Hancock and Kailfa.

Bye :mustache:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Gekko Moria
Sep 6 2011, 07:10 PM
Johnny
Sep 6 2011, 06:55 PM
Might as well complete my list.

1) Salome - as described above
2) Spacey, Ryuma - for almost opposite reasons
3) Boa, Chopperini, Iceburg, Kalifa, Moria
Sorry but could you rank that in a different way? Not trying to be rude but maybe you could post it as in suspicion level: high or something.

The numbering look a little odd to me and confusing. I mean i only know 1) is high on your suspicion list because of your post before.
Sure, if it helps you.

My list ordered by suspicion level. 1) being the highest.
Percentages added to reflect how likely I find a person/animal in the respective category to be mafia.

1) Salome (60%)
2) Spacey, Ryuma (55%)
3) Boa, Chopperini, Iceburg, Kalifa, Moria (45%)

As you see I remain fairly uncertain. :(


Ryuma's behavior leaves me puzzled but we will know soon enough now that he self-voted.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
I'm tingling with anticipation :mustache:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chopperini
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Well I hope you alls got items... ain't sure if Kalifa's gonna have one.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Sarfunkel
Member Avatar
Reliable Follower
:mustache: Lynch Status
With 9 players alive it takes 5 to achieve a lynch.

Ryuma [5] : Kalifa, Gekko Moria, Salome, Iceburg, Ryuma.

Not Voting [4] : Boa Hancock, Spacey, Chopperini, Johnny.

Lynch is achieved.


~Loading~
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gaimon
Member Avatar
Bishie-in-a-Box
Wasting no time, they all set upon he confused zombie. they ripped his limbs off his body and tore his stomache completely out. The air filled with a noxious stink that overpowered them

"Yohohohohohoho, guess it really is my time..."

With that, he burst into brilliant blue flames, laughing as the rest of his mangled body was burned to ashes...

Spoiler: click to toggle
[/i]

It is now night, you have 24 hours to send your actions to Sarfunkel and myself...
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
« Previous Topic · Day Threads · Next Topic »
Locked Topic