Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]


Locked Topic
Day 3
Topic Started: Sep 5 2011, 06:22 PM (1,938 Views)
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Gekko Moria
Sep 6 2011, 07:25 AM
Who would you use it on then Spacey? I mean if you want to use it it means you must have some kind of target in mind.
I don't really know. Personally I have one or two people I wouldn't use it on.

Ryuma flips mafia -> 2 vs. 6
I trust one player and exclude myself
-> 33% chance of hitting a mafia player
-> 66% chance of hitting a townie
-> some chance of hitting the townie targeted for the kill... :luffy:

Of course, suspicions play a part in all this as well.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chopperini
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
I'm glad you like my rhymes Ms. Snake,
For I have a confession to make.
I found my chest three rhymes ago,
I just kept going -- now you know.

I'm off peoples, be back in some hours, we gots plenty of time though so I ain't worried.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Salome
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Chopperini
Sep 6 2011, 08:32 AM
I'm glad you like my rhymes Ms. Snake,
For I have a confession to make.
I found my chest three rhymes ago,
I just kept going -- now you know.

I'm off peoples, be back in some hours, we gots plenty of time though so I ain't worried.
That's Mrs. Snake to you. I'm a happily married lesbian, for Enelssake!

Anyway, I'm off to do other things, might check back every now and then but that's it for now.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gaimon
Member Avatar
Bishie-in-a-Box
:mustache: Lynch Status
With 9 players alive it takes 5 to achieve a lynch.

Ryuma [3] : Kalifa, Gekko Moria, Salome

Not Voting [6] : Boa Hancock, Spacey, Chopperini, Johnny, Iceburg, Ryuma.

56 hours left.
Edited by Sarfunkel, Sep 6 2011, 10:28 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
I can't help but think what if Ryuma is town and there is already 2 mafia among the people that put their votes down. On the other hand Ryuma has jumped on every town lynch so far, so what if he is mafia and his scumbuddies are hesistant to finish him. I've never played a game where I had less of a read on people. I'm torn but I know this is a critical situation.

I'll be home in two hours. Hopefully this day will last that much longer.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Johnny
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Adding to this thought.

Ryuma. Why should I believe you are town? Can you reply to the points brought forward against you?

Gekko, Salome, Kalifa - what makes you town? Why are you lynching Ryuma? Why did you put your vote down so early?

Everybody else do you think the people that voted so far are less suspicious than those that didn't vote yet? Are you planning to vote Ryuma?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Salome
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
At this pace I doubt the day is going to end anytime soon.

Honestly, I think this is a very tricky situation.
We don't have much more than this to go on, no reports or any way of knowing we're sure but our own observations and opinions until the flip takes place.
Personally, I doubt a no lynch would be an option at this point in the game, as we can only guess at how many mafia there really are. It's all risky no matter how you look at things.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Gecko Moria
Member Avatar
adept treasure hunter
Johnny
Sep 6 2011, 12:42 PM
Adding to this thought.

Ryuma. Why should I believe you are town? Can you reply to the points brought forward against you?

Gekko, Salome, Kalifa - what makes you town? Why are you lynching Ryuma? Why did you put your vote down so early?

Everybody else do you think the people that voted so far are less suspicious than those that didn't vote yet? Are you planning to vote Ryuma?
The last day we have put plenty of suspicions upon Ryuma, when the day started i said i would wait untill he came and aswered them.

He came but just plain ignored them and talked about his ability, and right after Salome left i left for a little while as well, but not before checking who was online. And who was? Our friend Ryuma. There's a limit to how much you can outrun questions, and he's ignored it for far too long.

Aside from that theres the whole if Ryuma is maf my alignment is uncertain because of the ID scanner. Mafia have a tendency to avoid each other. Not exactly what we have been doing. Actually i was the second or so(?) to tell my suspicions about him.

I gave Ryuma plenty of time to answer, my patience is up.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Salome
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Johnny
Sep 6 2011, 12:42 PM
Adding to this thought.

Ryuma. Why should I believe you are town? Can you reply to the points brought forward against you?

Gekko, Salome, Kalifa - what makes you town? Why are you lynching Ryuma? Why did you put your vote down so early?

Everybody else do you think the people that voted so far are less suspicious than those that didn't vote yet? Are you planning to vote Ryuma?
I voted for Ryuma because as I already said, Ryuma is at the top of my suspect list right now.
I was hoping he would at least come and defend himself with these votes on him, but he was here earlier and he's not answering at all.
I have the feeling we're not going to get any answers, so I put down my vote, aside from hoping that holding his feet to the fire would motivate him.
Sorry for the block of text, but I want to be thorough on this.

He strangely and almost immediately jumped to the conclusion that the ID scanner he stole from Koshiro was insane because he had a bad feeling about Moria. Why would he check Moria out if he can't even accept the possibility that Moria could be innocent, like the scanner told him?
And yet, that very same day, he boldly said this:
Ryuma
 
The mafia tend to be less aggressive, unless they're bussing a scumbuddy. If Akainu flipped mafia I would have investigated M. M. C.

I don't like to reveal all my suspects. It gives the mafia a better idea about what lynches they can instigate, and what to do to make themselves look better.

And I don't like picking a suspected player to investigate. I like to pick someone no one would expect so the results are less likely to be tampered with. It's probably not a big deal in this set-up considering it's item based, but I don't want to take chances.

So Ryuma, why did you investigate Moria, someone you obviously suspected yourself, then?
Who do you suspect anyway?


And then, the very same day, he says this:
Ryuma
 
*copies and pastes Kailfa's post*

I honestly don't know what to say. I have no suspicions really. I feel stupid.


Ryuma
 
Vote Lynch: Saint Charlos

I don't think we'll agree on a target and we might as well get rid of him now.


Ryuma
 
Unvote At least he's trying to make relevant posts now, but I think he's a little confused about the double voting.


Ryuma
 
Vote Lynch: Hoe

After rereading and looking over my notes my top suspect is Kailfa, but I want to achieve a lynch so I'll vote Hoe (Who is also very high on my list).

I get the feeling that he's trying to go for an easy lynch, even to the point of outright stating he wants a lynch, but he doesn't motivate them at all.
What are these notes and why didn't he share them when he said he had no clue earlier on that same day?
He's just voting and unvoting at the drop of an hat and his posts contribute absolutely nothing to the scumhunt.

Other players have asked him questions and he's ignored them all. So why should I believe in his innocence, then?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Spacey
Member Avatar
3rd rate treasure hunter
Johnny
Sep 6 2011, 12:42 PM
Everybody else do you think the people that voted so far are less suspicious than those that didn't vote yet? Are you planning to vote Ryuma?
Just because they have voted already? No.

If Ryuma flips mafia that might give some insight but not all that much.

I am in favor of a Ryuma lynch so I will vote for him once everybody is okay with it. I am waiting for Ryuma, Iceburg, Boa and Kalifa because I don't think they have said anything since the Ryuma lynch came up.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Day Threads · Next Topic »
Locked Topic